Howard v. RNC: The Ninth Circuit on Video Texts and Whether Texts Are TCPA Calls

In Howard v. Republican National Committee (Jan. 13, 2026), the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of a TCPA suit over a political text with a tap-to-play video, holding it was not a prerecorded-voice call. Along the way it reaffirmed that a text message is a 'call' under the TCPA's autodialer provisions.

eConsent

eConsent Team

· Updated

Share
Person holding a smartphone displaying text messages in an office setting

Correction, October 17, 2026: An earlier version of this post misdescribed Howard v. RNC. It said the plaintiff won on a text-as-call question and that the case resolved a circuit split. In fact the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of the complaint. We rewrote the post from the opinion.

Short answer: In Howard v. Republican National Committee, No. 23-3826 (9th Cir. Jan. 13, 2026), the Ninth Circuit held that the TCPA’s ban on calls “using … an artificial or prerecorded voice” does not reach a text message carrying a video file that the recipient has to tap to play. It affirmed dismissal of the lawsuit. In explaining its reasoning, the court reaffirmed its earlier rule that a text message is a “call” for the TCPA’s autodialer provisions, so texts sent with an autodialer still need consent in the Ninth Circuit.

What happened in Howard v. RNC?

On October 24, 2020, the RNC sent Howard, an Arizona resident, a text message with a few sentences urging him to vote, a link, and a video of Ivanka Trump. The video downloaded to his phone automatically and showed as a thumbnail with a play button, but it did not play on its own. Howard conceded at oral argument that a recipient had to tap the thumbnail to hear it.

Howard sued under 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(1)(A)(iii) and § 227(b)(1)(B), which bar calls “using an artificial or prerecorded voice” without prior express consent. He argued the video’s audio was a prerecorded voice. The district court dismissed the complaint, and he appealed.

What did the Ninth Circuit hold?

The majority, in an opinion by Judge Collins, affirmed. It read the statute as reaching prerecorded voices used in the way a call is begun:

“By its plain terms, the statutory text in § 227(b)(1)(A)(iii) and § 227(b)(1)(B) only reaches the use of prerecorded voices in the manner in which a call is begun.” (Court’s summary)

Because the recipient had to choose to play the video after the text arrived, the “call” was made and initiated without a prerecorded voice playing, so it did not violate those provisions. Judge Rawlinson dissented and would have held the video text within the TCPA’s protections.

Did Howard hold that texts are calls?

Not as its holding, but it reaffirmed the rule. The Ninth Circuit decided in Satterfield v. Simon & Schuster (2009) that a text message is a “call” under the TCPA’s autodialer provision. Satterfield relied partly on deference to the FCC, which courts no longer give after the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in McLaughlin Chiropractic v. McKesson. In Howard, the court gave a reason that does not depend on the FCC: an auto-dialed text usually lights up the screen, makes a sound or vibrates the moment it arrives, an intrusion comparable to a ringing phone.

“That critical fact confirms that a text message is properly deemed to be a ‘call’ within the meaning of the TCPA.”

So in the Ninth Circuit, a marketing text sent with an autodialer to a cell phone without consent is still a TCPA violation, with statutory damages of $500 per message and up to $1,500 if willful or knowing.

How does Howard fit with the 2026 Do-Not-Call cases?

Howard concerned § 227(b), the autodialer and prerecorded-voice provisions. A separate question is whether texts count as “telephone calls” under the Do-Not-Call private right of action in § 227(c)(5). In July 2026 the Seventh Circuit said they do not (Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services), while a Pennsylvania federal court said they do. We cover that split in Are Text Messages “Calls” Under the TCPA’s Do-Not-Call Rules?

What should SMS marketers take from Howard?

  1. Texts sent with an autodialer still need consent. Howard does not loosen that in the Ninth Circuit.
  2. The video ruling is narrow. It turned on the video not playing until the recipient tapped it. Audio that plays automatically, or a prerecorded or AI voice call, is a different case.
  3. Keep consent evidence per number. Whatever the provision, a consumer’s documented prior express consent is the defense that works.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal advice. Talk to TCPA counsel about your own program.

Protect every lead. Prove every consent.

Tamper-evident certificates, session recordings, and real-time verification. Start capturing consent evidence today.

Start free trial

Stay ahead on TCPA compliance

Get regulatory updates, product news, and compliance tips. No spam.